Letters to the Editor: Respect for Judiciary and National Concerns

New Delhi, India Jul 16, 2026 ALN: Respect for judiciary

The judiciary is often seen as the guardian of the Constitution, tasked with upholding the rule of law and ensuring justice for all citizens. However, the perception of respect for this crucial institution is not merely a matter of tradition or expectation; it is something that must be actively cultivated through the conduct of its members. The recent comments regarding Justice Madhav Jamadar highlight the importance of actions that resonate with the public’s understanding of justice and fairness. Justice Jamadar has been lauded for protecting citizens' rights to protest, which is a fundamental aspect of democracy. By reprimanding police actions that stifle dissent, he has reinforced the idea that the judiciary stands as a bulwark against arbitrary state power.

In contrast, the treatment of litigants in prolonged legal battles raises serious concerns about the efficiency and empathy of the judicial system. The case mentioned, where a litigant is forced to sell her mangalsutra—an item of significant cultural and personal value—due to the financial strain of a lengthy legal process, illustrates a troubling reality. When courts grant adjournments without addressing the genuine pleas of individuals, it not only undermines the respect for the judiciary but also breeds contempt among the populace. The perception that the judiciary is out of touch with the struggles of ordinary citizens can lead to a significant erosion of trust in legal institutions.

It is essential for the judiciary to engage in introspection and reform to regain public confidence. This involves not only expediting cases but also ensuring that the human element of justice is not lost in the bureaucratic process. The judiciary must strive to uphold its integrity and earn the respect it seeks through actions that reflect a commitment to justice for all, especially for the most vulnerable members of society.

Rekha Sarin, Benaulim

On Wangchuk’s fast

Sonam Wangchuk's ongoing hunger strike has drawn attention to the pressing issue of autonomy for the Ladakh region. Wangchuk, a prominent social activist and engineer, has been a vocal advocate for the rights of the people of Ladakh, emphasizing the need for greater self-governance and protection of their unique cultural identity. His determination, demonstrated through an 18-day fast, reflects a deep commitment to these principles, but it also raises critical questions about the government's responsiveness to civil society's concerns.

The government's apparent indifference to Wangchuk's deteriorating health during his fast is troubling. It suggests a broader pattern of neglect regarding the aspirations and grievances of the people in Ladakh. By failing to engage in meaningful dialogue, the government risks escalating tensions and alienating a population that feels unheard and marginalized. Wangchuk's call for autonomy is not merely a personal crusade; it encapsulates the sentiments of many in Ladakh who fear that their cultural and environmental concerns are being overlooked in the face of rapid development and external pressures.

Moreover, the suggestion that Wangchuk should separate his activism from other political movements, such as the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), highlights the complexity of political activism in the region. While it is essential for activists to remain focused on their core issues, the interconnectedness of various social and political movements often complicates this endeavor. The government should recognize the broader implications of Wangchuk's activism and take proactive steps to engage with him and others in dialogue. This could lead to a more constructive resolution of the issues at hand and potentially avert further public unrest.

S Kamat, Mysuru

Strategic masterstroke

Prime Minister Narendra Modi's recent diplomatic tour, which included visits to Indonesia, Australia, and New Zealand, marks a significant shift in India's foreign policy approach. The trip not only underscores India's commitment to strengthening bilateral relations but also reflects a strategic pivot towards a more proactive engagement with countries in the Indo-Pacific region. This shift from a 'Look East' to an 'Act East' policy is crucial as global dynamics continue to evolve, particularly in light of rising geopolitical tensions.

In Indonesia, the blending of cultural diplomacy with defense cooperation is particularly noteworthy. The restoration of the Prambanan temple complex serves as a symbol of India's respect for cultural heritage, while the sale of BrahMos cruise missiles signals a commitment to enhancing regional security. Such initiatives illustrate India's multifaceted approach to diplomacy, where soft power complements hard power in fostering international relationships.

Similarly, the agreement with Australia to import uranium is a strategic move that aligns with India's ambitious goals for expanding its nuclear energy capacity. As India aims to achieve 100 GW of nuclear power by 2047, securing reliable sources of uranium is essential for meeting its energy needs and reducing dependence on fossil fuels.

Furthermore, the recent demonstrations against Indians in New Zealand highlight the importance of cultivating robust people-to-people connections. While government-to-government diplomacy is crucial, fostering cultural exchanges and mutual understanding at the grassroots level is equally important in building lasting trust between nations. Modi's tour serves as a reminder that diplomatic efforts must encompass a wide range of interactions, from economic partnerships to cultural collaborations, to effectively address the complexities of international relations.

Murali M Mallareddy, Vizag

Save Margao garden

The Margao municipal garden, a public space meant for recreation and relaxation, has recently become a focal point of controversy due to incidents of violence involving migrant workers. This situation reflects broader societal issues related to migration, labor, and urban public spaces. As more workers arrive in Goa seeking employment, the garden has inadvertently transformed into a gathering place for laborers, which has altered its character and raised concerns among local residents.

The changing dynamics of public spaces necessitate a thoughtful response from local authorities. It is essential to recognize that public gardens should serve the community by providing a safe and welcoming environment for all. The presence of large groups of laborers, particularly if associated with conflict, can deter families and children from using these spaces, thereby undermining their original purpose.

To address these challenges, the Margao Municipal Council and the district administration must explore alternative solutions. Establishing a designated labor facilitation center near the railway station could provide a suitable space for workers to gather without disrupting the recreational use of public gardens. Such a center would not only benefit employers and workers by streamlining the hiring process but also help restore the garden's status as a community space for leisure and enjoyment.

Ultimately, the goal should be to create an inclusive environment that respects the needs of all community members, whether they are local residents or migrant workers. By proactively addressing these issues, local authorities can help ensure that public spaces remain accessible and enjoyable for everyone.

Adelmo Fernandes, Vasco

National embarrassment

India's dismal ranking of 176th out of 177 in the 2026 Environment Performance Index is a stark indicator of the country's environmental challenges and underscores a pressing need for urgent action. Scoring a mere 22.46 compared to Estonia's 74.79, this ranking reflects systemic issues that have persisted despite numerous government initiatives aimed at environmental protection. The reality of air pollution, rising health risks, and environmental degradation cannot be dismissed as mere statistical anomalies or flawed methodologies.

Citizens across the country are grappling with the consequences of poor air quality and environmental neglect, from chronic respiratory diseases to the impacts of climate change on agriculture and livelihoods. The government's attempts to downplay these findings through rhetoric only serve to highlight a disconnect between official narratives and the lived experiences of ordinary people. The reality is that while political leaders may argue about the validity of rankings, the effects of environmental degradation are tangible and immediate for millions of citizens.

To address these critical issues, the government must move beyond defensive posturing and take decisive action. This includes implementing stringent air quality regulations, investing in sustainable infrastructure, and fostering transparency in environmental reporting. Building a robust data infrastructure that allows for accurate monitoring and accountability is essential for driving meaningful change. Only through genuine commitment and proactive measures can India hope to improve its environmental standing and safeguard the health and well-being of its citizens.

Dr Vijaykumar H K, Raichur